Constructive delivery

Constructive delivery, also known as symbolic delivery, is a legal concept where ownership of an item is transferred through a symbol or sign, rather than the actual physical item itself. This transfer of ownership is intended, but from a legal perspective, it has not yet been completed. Examples of constructive delivery include handing over the keys to a house or title deeds to a property. The Latin term for this procedure is traditio longa manu, meaning "delivery by extended hand," as opposed to traditio brevi manu, which refers to actual physical delivery. The acceptance of constructive delivery by the future owner is required for it to be legally valid .

Causes of using constructive delivery

There are several reasons why someone might choose to use constructive delivery in a transaction:

• Convenience: Constructive delivery allows for the transfer of ownership without the need for the physical item to be present. This can be more convenient for both parties involved, especially when the item is large or difficult to transport.
• Distance: When parties are geographically separated, it can be difficult to arrange for actual physical delivery. Constructive delivery allows for the transfer of ownership remotely.
• Time constraints: In some situations, actual physical delivery may not be possible due to time constraints. Constructive delivery can be used as a way to transfer ownership quickly and efficiently.
• Cost: Constructive delivery can be less expensive than actual physical delivery, as it eliminates the need to transport the item.
• Security: Constructive delivery can be used as a way to ensure the security of the item being transferred, as it eliminates the need to physically transport it.

It is important to note that some legal systems may have specific requirements or restrictions on the use of constructive delivery, and it may not be applicable or recognized in all cases.

Examples (5 types) of constructive delivery

Fig.1. Modes of delivery

There are several types of constructive delivery, including:

• Delivery of keys: This type of constructive delivery occurs when the keys to a property, such as a house or a car, are handed over to the new owner. This signifies the transfer of ownership, even though the physical property has not yet been transferred.
• Delivery of documents: This type of constructive delivery occurs when the title deeds or other legal documents related to a property are handed over to the new owner. This signifies the transfer of ownership, even though the physical property has not yet been transferred.
• Delivery of symbols: This type of constructive delivery occurs when a symbol or sign, such as a flag or a seal, is handed over to the new owner. This signifies the transfer of ownership, even though the physical item has not yet been transferred.
• Delivery of electronic data: This type of constructive delivery occurs when electronic data, such as software or digital files, is handed over to the new owner. This signifies the transfer of ownership, even though the physical item has not yet been transferred.
• Delivery of possession: This type of constructive delivery occurs when possession of an item is handed over to the new owner, such as delivery of possession of a warehouse or land. This signifies the transfer of ownership, even though the physical item has not yet been transferred.

It is important to note that some legal systems may have specific requirements or restrictions on the use of constructive delivery, and it may not be applicable or recognized in all cases.

Constructive delivery vs. real (actual) delivery

Constructive delivery and real delivery are two different ways of transferring ownership of an item.

Real delivery, also known as actual delivery or physical delivery, is the transfer of ownership of an item through the physical transfer of the item itself. This can be done by handing the item over to the new owner, or by shipping it to them. Real delivery is considered the traditional and most common method of transferring ownership.

Constructive delivery, on the other hand, is the transfer of ownership through a symbol or sign, rather than the physical item itself. This can be done by handing over the keys to a property, the title deeds to a property, or other legal documents related to the item. Constructive delivery can be used when the physical transfer of the item is not possible or practical, such as when the parties are geographically separated or the item is too large to be easily transported.

It is important to note that some legal systems may have specific requirements or restrictions on the use of constructive delivery, and it may not be applicable or recognized in all cases. Also, the acceptance of the item by the future owner is required for constructive delivery to be legally valid.

Risks related to constructive delivery

There are several risks associated with constructive delivery:

• Legal uncertainty: Constructive delivery may not be recognized or enforceable in all legal systems, or may have specific requirements or restrictions that must be met. This can create uncertainty and potential legal challenges.
• Risk of fraud: Constructive delivery relies on trust between the parties involved. If one party fails to deliver the item as promised, it may be difficult to prove fraud or enforce the agreement.
• Risk of disputes: Constructive delivery may create confusion or disputes over the transfer of ownership. For example, if the seller retains possession of the keys or documents, there may be disputes over whether the transfer of ownership has occurred.
• Risk of non-acceptance: Constructive delivery requires the acceptance of the item by the future owner, if the future owner does not accept the item, the transaction may not be valid.
• Risk of non-performance: Constructive delivery is an agreement of the parties, if one of the parties does not fulfill the agreement, the transaction may be invalid.
• Risk of delay: If the transfer of ownership is delayed, it may be difficult to prove that constructive delivery has occurred.

It is important to note that these risks can be mitigated by including specific language in the agreement outlining the terms of the constructive delivery, and by obtaining legal advice before proceeding with the transaction.

Situations where constructive delivery is used

Constructive delivery is often used in situations where the physical transfer of an item is not possible or practical, such as:

• Real estate transactions: Constructive delivery can be used in the sale of real estate, where the keys or title deeds to a property are transferred to the new owner, even though the physical property has not yet been transferred.
• Distance transactions: When the parties involved are geographically separated, it can be difficult to arrange for actual physical delivery. Constructive delivery allows for the transfer of ownership remotely.
• Time constraints: In some situations, actual physical delivery may not be possible due to time constraints. Constructive delivery can be used as a way to transfer ownership quickly and efficiently.
• Security: Constructive delivery can be used as a way to ensure the security of the item being transferred, as it eliminates the need to physically transport it.
• Electronic data: Constructive delivery can be used to transfer ownership of electronic data, such as software or digital files, where the physical delivery of the data storage device is not possible or practical.
• Possession: Constructive delivery can be used to transfer possession of an item, such as delivery of possession of a warehouse or land.

It is important to note that some legal systems may have specific requirements or restrictions on the use of constructive delivery, and it may not be applicable or recognized in all cases, and the acceptance of the item by the future owner is required for constructive delivery to be legally valid.

Footnotes

Constructive delivery — recommended articles

Indemnity bond — Torrens system — Tenancy at Will — Deed of surrender — Limitation of liability — Warranty of title — Shipping terms — Executed agreement — Tri party agreement

References

• Anderson C., (2015), Delivery of goods in the custody of a third party: operation and basis in "Edinburgh Law Review, 19 (2)"
• Chambers L. (2016), 'The keepers of the keys: remedies and legal obligations following misappropriations of cryptocurrency in "Butterworths Journal of International Banking and Financial Law"
• Dukeminier J., Krier J. E., Alexander G. S., Schill M., Strahilevitz L. J., (2017), Property: Concise Edition. Aspen Casebook Series, Wolters Kluwer Law & Business
• Kochan D. J., Massey C. R., (2018), Emanuel Law Outlines for Property Keyed to Dukeminier, Krier, Alexander, Schill, Strahilevitz Emanuel Law Outlines, Wolters Kluwer Law & Business
• McCormack C., Taylor M. J., (2006), Electronic delivery of oral feedback on graphic design projects, in "Proceedings of the 23rd annual ascilite conference: Who’s learning? Whose technology?"
• Melville R. D., (1915),A manual of the principles of Roman law relating to persons, property, and obligations, W. Green and Son Limited Law Publishers
• Miller R. L., Jentz G. A., (2010). Business Law Today: The Essentials, Cengage Advantage Books
• Requirement of Delivery in Gifts of Personalty - Schenker v. Moodhel, 3, (1939), in "Maryland Law Review Volume 3 Issue 3 Article 9"
• Smith J. C., (2018), Glannon Guide to Property: Learning Property Through Multiple Choice Questions and Analysis. Glannon Guides, Wolters Kluwer Law & Business, 2018