Unascertained goods are goods that are not specific. Whether the good is considered unascertained is of definite importance in the passing of property between seller and buyer . It is clear that the test of whether or not the goods are 'specific' is to be applied at the moment of contracting. Goods which do not meet the test are initially unascertained, but may afterwards become identified and agreed upon at which point they are said to become ascertained .
Kinds of unascertained goods
- The goods are to be manufactured by the seller. In this case, they will usually become ascertained as a result of the process of manufacture, although, if the producer is making similar goods for two or more customers, some further actions may be necessary to make it clear which goods have been appropriated to which customer.
- The goods may be part of an undivided bulk. If the seller has 1,000 tons of Western White Wheat on board of a cargo ship and sells 500 tons to buyer A and 500 tons to buyer B, the Wheat is an unascertained good, since it is not possible to tell which 500 tons have been sold to which purchaser. Important practical consequences flow from this rule: in this situation, the goods became ascertained only when it can be established which Part of the cargo is assigned to which contract.So, in Karlhamns Oljefabriker v Eastport Navigation (1982), 22,000 tons of copra were filled up on board a ship in the Philippines, of which 6,000 tons were sold to a Swedish customer. At this stage, of course, the goods were unascertained. The ship called at Rotterdam and at Hamburg on its way to Sweden and 16,000 tons were offloaded at these two ports. It was held that the goods became ascertained on the realization of discharge in Hamburg, as it was then possible to say with confidence that the remainder of the cargo was destined for the purchaser.
- The goods are being sold by a generic description, such as 500 tons Western White Wheat. In such an instance, the seller could fulfil the contract by delivering any 500 tons of Western White Wheat provided that it was of satisfactory quality and met all the requirements. If the seller was a trader in wheat, he or she might well have more than 500 tons of wheat but would not be obligated to use that wheat to perform the contract; he or she could and often would choose to buy additional wheat on the market to fulfil the order. Where there is an active market, sellers and buyers may be entering into a compound series of sales and purchases according to their view of how the market is moving and leaving who gets what wheat to be sorted out later. This is particularly likely where the sales are for delivery at a later date rather than for immediate shipment. In this situation, the seller may form procedures to use a parcel of wheat to deliver to buyer A and another parcel to buyer B. Usually, forming of these procedures will not make the goods ascertained until the seller makes some act of appropriation which prevents a change of mind.
- Furston M., 2012 p.21
- Macleod J., 2009 par.20.8-9
- Furston M., 2012 p.21-22
- Griffiths M., 2002 p.141-142
- Furston M. (2012)., Sale & Supply of Goods, Cavendish Publishing Limited, London, United Kingdom
- Griffiths M., Griffiths I. (2002)., Law for Purchasing and Supply, Pearson Education Limited, Essex, United Kingdom
- Macleod J. (2009)., Consumer Sales Law: The Law Relating to Consumer Sales and Financing of Goods, Routlege-Cavendish Taylor & Francis Group, Milton, United Kingdom
Author: Jakub Irauth